THE GHOST OF THE DECREE: WHY EXECUTIVE FIAT CANNOT COEXIST WITH UGANDA’S 1995 CONSTITUTION

In my view as a constitutional and human rights barrister-at-law, understanding our present governance requires confronting our past.

17 Nov 2026 - 09:29
0
THE GHOST OF THE DECREE: WHY EXECUTIVE FIAT CANNOT COEXIST WITH UGANDA’S 1995 CONSTITUTION
THE WRITER IS LONDON-BASED BARRISTER PETER MAGOMU MASHATE, AN ADMINISTRATIVE, CONSTITUTIONAL & HUMAN RIGHTS BARRISTER-AT-LAW CALLED TO THE BAR BY THE HONOURABLE SOCIETY OF LINCOLN’S INN OF COURT LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM.

ANALYSIS

BY BARRISTER PETER MAGOMU MASHATE 

Whenever modern debates flare over presidential directives, ministerial statutory instruments, or executive orders in Uganda, I find myself returning to a fundamental constitutional question: where does lawful executive administration end, and the ghost of rule by decree begin?

In my view as a constitutional and human rights barrister-at-law, understanding our present governance requires confronting our past.

Formal rule by decree in Uganda began in February 1966—with its most absolute, militarized form taking root on January 25, 1971—and definitively ended on October 8, 1995, when our current Constitution was promulgated.

Across those three turbulent decades, governance by executive fiat evolved through distinct political phases before being legally dismantled by modern constitutional architecture.

The Trajectory of Executive Fiat

I trace the genesis of rule by decree to the Prelude of February 1966 to January 1971.

During the 1966 Mengo Crisis, Prime Minister Milton Obote suspended the 1962 Independence Constitution, assumed all state powers, and imposed the interim "Pigeonhole" Constitution without parliamentary debate.

Even after the 1967 Republican Constitution restored a nominal Parliament, governance relied heavily on emergency powers and executive decrees.

Pure, institutionalized rule by decree arrived on February 2, 1971, days after Major General Idi Amin’s coup. Through Legal Notice No. 1 of 1971, Amin dissolved Parliament, suspended constitutional supremacy, and vested all legislative and executive powers exclusively in himself.

Following Amin’s ouster in 1979, a Transitional Era (1979–1995) saw successive administrations—from the Uganda National Liberation Front and the 1980 Military Commission to Tito Okello’s junta and the early National Resistance Army/Movement government via Legal Notice or Proclamation No. 1 of 1986—govern through proclamations, decrees, and ordinances while key parts of the 1967 Constitution remained suspended.

That era closed permanently on October 8, 1995, when the promulgation of the 1995 Constitution restored parliamentary sovereignty and constitutional supremacy.

Intended Advantages Versus Destabilizing Reality

Every regime that resorted to rule by decree justified it as an urgent necessity to bypass political gridlock and restore order. Yet, looking objectively at our history, the cure consistently proved far worse than the disease.

First, regimes promised speed, arguing that decrees bypassed slow legislative debates during security crises. In reality, they birthed arbitrary governance, enabling laws passed on personal whims—from banning mini-skirts to expelling citizens—without public scrutiny.

Second, strongmen claimed fiat would break factional paralysis between federal kingdoms, such as Buganda, and the central government. Instead, destroying negotiated consensus collapsed institutional legitimacy and deepened sectarian resentment.

Third, decrees were touted as tools for economic restructuring, enabling swift nationalization during the 1972 "Economic War." Far from empowering Ugandans, unpredictable decrees shattered investor confidence, collapsed domestic production, and triggered hyperinflation.

Finally, while transitional regimes in 1979 and 1986 used decrees to restore order in the absence of a sitting parliament, those decrees routinely ousted the jurisdiction of civil courts—immunizing state agents from accountability, eroding judicial independence, and normalizing extrajudicial violence.

Why Rule by Law Is Not the Rule of Law?

In jurisprudence, I maintain a strict distinction between the "Rule of Law" and "rule by law."

Rule by decree can never amount to the Rule of Law; it is merely rule by law—rule by man dressed in legal stationery.

Under rule by law, a ruler uses legal instruments—decrees and legal notices—as weapons to enforce personal will. The law binds the citizen, while the ruler sits above it, free to alter or suspend the rules at will.

Conversely, the true Rule of Law, anchored in A.V. Dicey’s classical doctrine that underpins Ugandan jurisprudence, demands that no individual stands above the law. It requires transparent, representative lawmaking adjudicated by an independent judiciary.

Even if a benevolent ruler issues a decree with a socially beneficial outcome, the process itself violates the Rule of Law because it lacks democratic legitimacy and institutional accountability.

An Irreconcilable Clash with the 1995 Constitution

Structurally and legally, rule by decree cannot live side by side with Uganda’s 1995 Constitution. The Constituent Assembly engineered our supreme law as a direct antidote to governance by fiat through four entrenched pillars:

Constitutional Supremacy (Article 2): Any decree, executive order, or action inconsistent with the Constitution is automatically null and void.

Ban on Unconstitutional Takeovers(Article 3): Suspending or abrogating the Constitution—the classic prerequisite for ruling by decree—is treason, and citizens are mandated to resist it only by lawful means.

Exclusive Legislative Authority (Article 79): Only Parliament can enact primary laws for the peace, order, development, and good governance of Uganda.

Strict Emergency Limits(Article 110): Even during a state of emergency, presidential powers are strictly time-bound, require swift parliamentary approval, and cannot suspend non-derogable rights under Article 44, such as habeas corpus and freedom from torture.

How Our Courts Guard the Boundary

While watchdogs like the Uganda Law Society rightly scrutinize modern executive overreach, I take encouragement from how Uganda’s superior courts have consistently enforced the boundary between lawful executive administration and unconstitutional rule by decree.

In Nakasero Market Sitting Tenants (NAMASITE) Ltd v. Nakasero Market Sitting Vendors & Traders Ltd, the Court of Appeal held unequivocally that a presidential directive not anchored in an Act of Parliament carries no force of law—a principle echoed in Horizon Coaches Ltd v. Edward Rurangaranga.

Even during the COVID-19 pandemic in Male Mabirizi v. Attorney General, the Constitutional Court clarified that presidential directives only gained legal force because the Minister of Health translated them into formal statutory instruments under the Public Health Act.

Similarly, in Uganda Court Bailiffs Association Ltd v. Attorney General, the Constitutional Court struck down executive directives requiring court orders to receive "clearance" from Resident District Commissioners or security officials before enforcement.

Meanwhile, in Muwanga Kivumbi v. Attorney General and Kwizera v. Attorney General, the courts reaffirmed that delegated statutory instruments cannot exceed their parent Acts (ultra vires), nor can executive policy directives take legal effect without parliamentary sanction.

Executive dominance may periodically test the boundaries of our constitutional order, but our jurisprudence speaks with one voice: a presidential letter or ministerial instrument is not a decree. Under the 1995 Constitution, the ghost of rule by decree remains permanently outlawed from Uganda’s legal landscape.

THE WRITER IS LONDON-BASED BARRISTER PETER MAGOMU MASHATE, AN ADMINISTRATIVE, CONSTITUTIONAL & HUMAN RIGHTS BARRISTER-AT-LAW CALLED TO THE BAR BY THE HONOURABLE SOCIETY OF LINCOLN’S INN OF COURT LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM.

John Kusolo

John Kusolo is a Pastor, Sports Enthusiast and Ugandan journalist with Nile Chronicles News (NCN). With a strong commitment to journalistic excellence, he is recognized for his dedication, goal-oriented approach, and ability to thrive in challenging environments. Kusolo brings focused motivation and professionalism to his reporting and media assignments.

Comments (0)

User